It seems to be a cliche that if someone is missing (presumed dead) that they are actually being held somewhere, waiting to be rescued by a band of adventurers like a certain Marshall of Furyondy or leader of the Shield Lands!
I DM Ratik (currently 578), and might get to the battle of Kalmar Pass and the "death" of Alain, but I saw an adventure that hinted he might still be alive. Does anyone know how that turned out?
Greyhawk Wars left the fate of Osson open to doubt. Any chance that he actually just got killed?
Well, the LGG, on page 91, states that Alain's lieutenants saw him slain. So Alain is definitely "dead."
As for Osson, I don't recall seeing anything definitive on him. He might have retreated with his army back across the Thelly. Or, perhaps he died in battle. I'm not sure. _________________ Mystic's web page: http://melkot.com/mysticscholar/index.html
Mystic's blog page: http://mysticscholar.blogspot.com/
Well, the LGG, on page 91, states that Alain's lieutenants saw him slain. So Alain is definitely "dead."
In addition to being raised from the dead, in a fantasy world there is also the possibility of them having seen some type of illusion or doppleganger or that they were bribed into lying about what they witnessed.
I DM Ratik (currently 578), and might get to the battle of Kalmar Pass and the "death" of Alain, but I saw an adventure that hinted he might still be alive. Does anyone know how that turned out?
Yes. Will PM so there's no spoiler for those that might play it someday.
Actually I think raise dead, resurrection, and clone, are used to often IMHO. Not a problem in my game raising a dead person back to the living requires the aid of a priest of the dead no other deity save a god of the dead can release the soul of one that has passed away IMC.
Clone spells by their very nature can not be used by a mage to make sure a copy of himself lives if he should pass. As the spell states once they have knowledge of each other they seek each other out until their is only one. I rule that once the wizard casts the spells to create a copy of himself the nature of the spell causes him to destroy the copy he just requested, as he will be aware of its existence.
In addition to being raised from the dead, in a fantasy world there is also the possibility of them having seen some type of illusion or doppleganger . . .
Though a possibility, he was "pulled down" by Gnolls, a species that happens to find humans a "tasty snack food."
SirXaris wrote:
or that they were bribed into lying about what they witnessed.
One might wonder what "they" hoped to gain, however. Baroness Evaleigh (Gord's former lover) is now Ruler and she gained the throne legally. Not all "nobles" within the barony are going to agree to an usurpation (by whoever did the bribing). Why then should the lieutenants lie about Alain's death? What do "they" gain? An "iffy" proposition, at best.
Alain is quite dead. I believe he actually was eaten by the gnolls that killed him (ask PSmdeger for confirmation of that). Perhaps his skull still serves as the wine cup (or is a trophy) of some humanoid leader in Spinecastle... _________________ - Moderator/Admin (in some areas)/Member -
Alain is quite dead . . . Perhaps his skull still serves as the wine cup (or is a trophy) of some humanoid leader in Spinecastle...
The perfect reason for launching an invasion of Spinecastle!
"Death to the Gnolls! We must return Alain's skull for proper burial!"
Wanted!
Mighty heroes to rescue the remains of our beloved Prince Alain! Do you have the courage to enter Spinecastle? If so, contact our Captain of the Guard -- PSmedger -- for details!
Well, the LGG, on page 91, states that Alain's lieutenants saw him slain. So Alain is definitely "dead."...
...but:
SirXaris wrote:
...in a fantasy world there is also the possibility of them having seen some type of illusion or doppleganger...
-Unlikley, but possible. To what end? To conceal a capture? To conceal a defection?
SirXaris wrote:
...they were bribed into lying about what they witnessed...
-Who would have bribed them? To what end? But possible.
It's also possible that they lied simply to cover up the fact that they left Alain to die--not exactly a heroic moment.
Either way, there are magical ways to detect lies. There are also magical ways to conceal them!
Another possibility is that people see what they see, and then make assumptions. A historical example is the young Kit Carson. He was with another guy when they were attacked by indians. Kit escaped, and naturally told everyone of the death of his companion. Young Kit's career was nearly cut short when the guy dragged himself in a few days later, not so happy about being abandoned by that rookie.
Sometimes, eyewitness testimony isn't worth the proverbial warm bucket of spit. It depends on the eyewitness--in this case, Alain's "lieutenants"--any of whom could be wrong for any number of reasons. Who were they anyway? (If I get around to it, most of them will be the sons of Bone March aristocrats).
SirXaris wrote:
...In addition to being raised from the dead...
...that too!
But:
Mystic-Scholar wrote:
...Though a possibility, he was "pulled down" by Gnolls, a species that happens to find humans a "tasty snack food."
...and...
Cebrion wrote:
...I believe he actually was eaten by the gnolls that killed him...
That would pretty well do it, if the gnolls ate him. That assumes that they even killed him, and that if they killed him, that they ate him. Gnolls might like to eat people, but they're smart enough to know that they can buy a lot more people chow with the gold they can get for a ransom. Of course, that beings up the question of why there was no offer of ransom.
Or was there?
Cebrion wrote:
...Perhaps his skull still serves as the wine cup (or is a trophy) of some humanoid leader in Spinecastle...
-You'd think that word would get out from all the bragging that the owner of such a trophy would do. A modest gnoll chieftain? Or a smart one?
Wouldn't Alain's skull make an intersting magic item? Even an artifact?
There's one way to find out:
Mystic-Scholar wrote:
...The perfect reason for launching an invasion of Spinecastle!
"Death to the Gnolls! We must return Alain's skull for proper burial!"
On Osson:
Mystic-Scholar wrote:
...As for Osson, I don't recall seeing anything definitive on him. He might have retreated with his army back across the Thelly. Or, perhaps he died in battle. I'm not sure.
-Yeah. He seems to have dropped into a black hole.
Any other examples?
Ashur wrote:
jamesdglick wrote:
...I saw an adventure that hinted he might still be alive. Does anyone know how that turned out?
Yes. Will PM so there's no spoiler for those that might play it someday.
-Got it, thanks. Exactly what I needed. I'll accept the source as authoritative.
Perhaps others might consult Ashur? Some people might be surprised.
As for Osson, I don't recall seeing anything definitive on him. He might have retreated with his army back across the Thelly. Or, perhaps he died in battle. I'm not sure.
From Ivid the Undying (v4), pg 32
"The dungeons of the royal palace contain an unknown number of wretches suffering the Endless Death. Here, they are tortured by priests of Hextor, given a ring of regeneration, and then tortured all over again. Such treatment renders the victims insane very swiftly. The current victims include Spidasa, Censor of Medegia, and it is possible that Chelor, Herzog of South Province, is similarly tormented—though some say he is dead. Some folk believe that Osson of Almor is similarly imprisoned in the unspeakable dungeons, swarming with evil priests, lesser and least baatezu, undead of most kinds, and worse."
pg.85
"Kalreth is a general of the Companion Guard, and he hunted down Osson in Medegia and razed much of that land."
From pg 19 of The Greyhawk Wars
"Though Osson planned an orderly dash for safety, it was not to be. As the cavalry charged across the Flanmi River, most of its officers fell to the bowmen of the entrenched Aerdi Army. So many fell, in fact, that even the energetic and brilliant commandant could not reign in the cavalry. Before even securing the field, every horseman who still drew breath rode hard for the hills and the safety of Sunndi. From there, the ragged line of cavalry wormed its way home by way of the Iron League. Commandant of the Field Osson of Chathold did not return, and his final fate remains a mystery. The Great Almorian Raid had finally met its end."
Kalreth is a general of the Companion Guard, and he hunted down Osson in Medegia . . . Commandant of the Field Osson of Chathold did not return, and his final fate remains a mystery . . . Some folk believe that Osson of Almor is similarly imprisoned in the unspeakable dungeons . . .
Poor Thrommel, imprisoned in the Temple of . . . err, I mean Osson, poor Osson!
Oh, and Nellisir? I went ahead and bookmarked your Blog. Happy?
I am, actually. :) I'd like to get back to posting in it sometime. I graduate in December, so probably beginning of next year? I do have snippets from old writings that I'm trying to put up on occasion, but there's no real rhyme or reason to it.
...I believe he actually was eaten by the gnolls that killed him...
That would pretty well do it, if the gnolls ate him. That assumes that they even killed him, and that if they killed him, that they ate him. Gnolls might like to eat people, but they're smart enough to know that they can buy a lot more people chow with the gold they can get for a ransom. Of course, that beings up the question of why there was no offer of ransom.
Or was there?
There is no assumption that Alain us dead. The snippet...
"In 586 CY, Alain led a force of men and dwarves into the Bone March in an attempt to retake Spinecastle with the baron's grudging support. The attack failed, and Alain's surviving lieutenants watched as the young lord was dragged from his horse by gnolls and slain.
---LGG p. 91"
...is not really very open to interpretation, though the pic in the LGG entitled called "The Death of Alain" could, I guess, be interpreted to mean that the pictured gnolls pulling Alain from his wild-eyed horse "killed" Alain's will to remain mounted upon his doomed steed (which also subsequently got eaten).
And humanoids don't really ransom people either. Why? Because people don't trust them enough to even set up such an exchange. That probably has much to do with ninety-nine out of a hundred such exchanges ending up being ambushes. Even if they do go off okay, you might get a captive back with their arms eaten off. "You'z never said we'z had to give 'im back whole. Hur, hur, hur!"
You see, evil scum just don't have much of a code of honor about following rules and such (even the Lawful Evil ones). For gnolls, it is also against their back biting/ankle biting nature. Why have one captive, when you can have captive, maybe get more captives, and even get paid more. Besides, it is not smart to hand back war leaders (even stupid ones) that can unite your enemies to enough of an extent that they will invade you(not to mention that most stupid war leaders will usually learn form their mistakes and do better the next time around).
jamesdglick wrote:
Cebrion wrote:
...Perhaps his skull still serves as the wine cup (or is a trophy) of some humanoid leader in Spinecastle...
-You'd think that word would get out from all the bragging that the owner of such a trophy would do. A modest gnoll chieftain? Or a smart one?
Wouldn't Alain's skull make an interesting magic item? Even an artifact?
There's one way to find out:
Mystic-Scholar wrote:
...The perfect reason for launching an invasion of Spinecastle!
"Death to the Gnolls! We must return Alain's skull for proper burial!"
Alain had a "perfect" reason for invading too. Look what it got him. If only there was somebody even more brave and foolish that Alain who would take up such a cause...
Ah yes, enter the adventurers.
Alain's skull or some other bits could make for some interesting items.
* The Skullcup of Victory
* The Knucklebone Necklace (made of Alain's finger bones)
...and so on. _________________ - Moderator/Admin (in some areas)/Member -
Last edited by Cebrion on Thu Dec 22, 2016 4:12 am; edited 1 time in total
Alain had a "perfect" reason for invading too. Look what it go him. If only there was somebody even more brave and foolish that Alain who would take up such a cause . . . Ah yes, enter the adventurers.
True! Why, even Cebrion's PC is involved in a mission to Spinecastle . . . as we "speak!"
There is no assumption that Alain us dead. The snippet...
"In 586 CY, Alain led a force of men and dwarves into the Bone March in an attempt to retake Spinecastle with the baron's grudging support. The attack failed, and Alain's surviving lieutenants watched as the young lord was dragged from his horse by gnolls and slain.
---LGG p. 91"
...is not really very open to interpretation...
Better, but unfortunately, LGG is often written in 1st person rather than 3rd person omniscient (The settling of the Sheldomar by the Neheli and Rhola springs to mind).
Which is why I'm skeptical in the first place.
Of course, you can only distrust the LGG (and it's predecessors) so much before you end up with gibberish, I supose. But Alain being missing just seems ripe, a al Prince T, etc.
Cebrion wrote:
...You see, evil scum just don't have much of a code of honor about following rules and such (even the Lawful Evil ones)...
-Evil scum follow rules if they want credibility for the next ransom. Think Boss Dhaely (Really? Another example of EGG's clever name creation ) and the ransoming of Evaleigh. Think kidnappers in the real world.
Cebrion wrote:
...And humanoids don't really ransom people either...
-In my campaign, they do.
Cebrion wrote:
...And humanoids don't really ransom people either. Why? Because people don't trust them enough to even set up such an exchange. That probably has much to do with ninety-nine out of a hundred such exchanges ending up being ambushes. Even if they do go off okay, you might get a captive back with their arms eaten off. "You'z never said we'z had to give 'im back whole. Hur, hur, hur!"
-I just remember reading something GH related where that happened, although it may not have been humanoids. When you cut a deal, you do have to specify.
Of course, even with arms eaten off, Evaleigh would want him back.
Or would she?
You're also assuming that they'd ransom him to the folks back home. There are other options, heh, heh, heh...
Cebrion wrote:
...Alain's skull or some other bits could make for some interesting items.
* The Skullcup of Victory
* The Knucklebone Necklace (made of Alain's finger bones)
...and so on.
-I vote for putting him on wheels turning his skeleton into movable hat rack.
Cebrion wrote:
"The Death of Alain" could, I guess, be interpreted to mean that the pictured gnolls pulling Alain from his wild-eyed horse "killed" Alain's will to remain mounted upon his doomed steed (which also subsequently got eaten)...
-We must reclaim the Bone March to rescue Alain's horse, old what's-his-name!
The party is in trouble as it seems a bard and the half-orc are often left in a leadership role. Did I mention we have a smart alack half-ogre and a priest of Hextor that makes Grumpy the dwarf look cheerful and happy.
Instead of creating a new thread, I thought I'd just bring this one back, since it involves Alain:
Any ideas of what D&D 3.5 class Alain, heir apparent of Ratik, may have been? His armor apparently had the mark of Heironeous etched on it, but anyone can worship Heironeous, not just paladins, although it strongly implies a LG or NG alignment. Maybe paladin, although if he were, you'd think it would have been mentioned. Fighter would be good, but so would marshal or knight.
In my case, My PCs are in 578 CY, and I'd like to have something ready "just in case". The don't know what his destiny is, after all. They could even be the ones who get him in trouble. Or maybe change his destiny?
It depends on the edition, but I'd make Alain a fighter or cavalier or the like rather than a paladin. He could be a paladin, but I don't think there's anything that portrays him as particularly virtuous, just ambitious. " Many whispered that Alain was encouraged in these ambitions by his step-family, particularly the count of Knurl, whose position between Bone March, North Province, and Nyrond was grossly precarious." That doesn't sound like a crusading paladin, it sounds like an ambitious noble. The cavalier class from 1st edition's Unearthed Arcana sounds perfect to me, especially the immunity to fear part that hastens his doom.
Researching Alain brought up this bit from Living Greyhawk Journal #5, page 30: "A strange beggar has appeared on the docks of Marner, Ratik's capital. He claims to be a squire of Alain, the lost husband of lady Baroness Evaleigh, and that Alain is still alive. Is this just another sadly confused veteran of the Bone March campaign?"
For what it's worth, Zavoda's index has Alain mentioned in the following sources:
Saga of Old City, page 241
Living Greyhawk Gazetteer, 36, 90, 91
Living Greyhawk Journal #1, 30
Living Greyhawk Journal #5, 30
The Living Greyhawk County of Knurl Gazetteer also mentions him briefly. It also has Lady Evaleigh far too young, in my opinion, claiming she was born 565 CY. Since she seemed to be a full-grown adult in Saga of Old City, she should be older than that (she would also have been only 13 or 14 when she married Alain in 579, which isn't impossible, but gets uncomfortable when you realize she was messing around with Gord the Rogue prior to that).
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Canonfire! is a production of the Thursday Group in assocation with GREYtalk and Canonfire! Enterprises