I agree with the Unofficial Errata; when this move is performed, the character's Weapon
Mastery should be counted as no higher than Basic level, since this is a brute force attack.
I also really recommend that whenever a character is employing the Smash maneuver, it must
be his only attack for the round; he must give up all multiple attacks including any
additional off-hand attacks.
And take note that the Strength score is added on as bonus damage on top of the base damage
for the weapon; such bonus damage is never multiplied because of effects that cause double
damage (on page 105, steps 7 and 8 in the Attack Roll Checklist clearly state this)."
I think chatdemon and darva both abandoned this forum
I, although BX is not my first choice of editions, would have to say at first glance that the two systems are not meant to work together, since the rule cyclopedia did cover the boxed sets the other stuff came from, and included the parts the designer/editor wanted included, we can only assume.
If you come up with a homebrew conversion of the special maneuvers to the mastery system tho, be sure and share with the rest of the class _________________ Salud, Maria
Olmanifesto, my Amedio blog:
Posted: Fri Jan 02, 2009 9:07 pm Post subject: Weapon Master from Later Boxed Sets
My answser in my campaign after trying them, was to not use Weapon Mastery. I believe it was listed as optional. My players didn't have a problem ignoring it after we tried it. To get to that level where it matters, the fighters are already so bad-**** that Weapon Master on top of it seemed silly. As I recall, it was so silly that the players were laughing at how powerful they were with it.
No, I didn't run the later boxed set editions of D&D in Greyhawk but with the ability scores more similiar to OD&D than AD&D, I would think the same concept applies to anyone thinking of using (BXCM)D&D weapon mastering in OD&D.
B2 is the first module I ever played and I still tend to go back to it for the start of any Oerth campagin I try to run, I have also used Palace of the silver princess but nothing quite holds up to the keep on the borderlands. _________________ aiza
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum